Browse all reviews by letter     A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 0 - 9

New Zealand 2016
Directed by
Lee Tamahori
103 minutes
Rated M

Reviewed by
Chris Thompson
3.5 stars


Synopsis: In the 1960s on the East Coast of New Zealand, a long-standing feud exists between two Maori sheep-shearing families; the Mahanas, headed by grandfather,Tamihana (Temuera Morrison) and the Poatas headed by Rupenia (Jim Moriarty). Their differences extend from the family into the commercial arena as they vie for shearing contracts and compete against each other in the local Golden Shears competition. When Tamihana’s hold on the Mahana family is challenged by 14-year-old Simeon (Akuhata Keefe) the old man banishes the boy and his family to a remote shack belonging to his grandmother, Ramona (Nancy Brunning). As the banished family struggles to make ends meet, Simeon slowly learns the truth about his family history and discovers that the mythology of the romance between his grandfather and grandmother has a much darker reality to it, one that calls into the question what lies at the heart of the conflict between the rival families.

It’s been a good year for New Zealand films with Taika Waititi’s very funny Hunt For The Wilderpeople and Arepa Kahi’s excellent documentary Poi E (The Story of our Song).  Now comes this powerful family drama  which marks the return of Lee Tamahori to the New Zealand screen for the first time since his directorial debut in 1994 with the astounding Once Were Warriors.  Since then, he’s been in Hollywood directing a host of thrillers, action movies and even an instalment of the James Bond franchise. Mahana is quite a gear shift, focusing much more on characters and their relationships.

The story comes from the novel ‘Bulibasha: King of the Gypsies’ by WitiIhimaera (who also wrote the novel on which Niki Caro’s 2002 movie Whale Rider was based). It’s been beautifully adapted for the screen by John Collee who, apart from his Oscar-nominated screenplay for Peter Weir’s Master and Commander (2003) and his Oscar-winning screenplay for Happy Feet (2006), co-wrote this year’s lyrical islander love story, Tanna, with Martin Butler and Bentley Dean.  From its clever opening scene where all the lines of power and struggle are sharply established through a disarmingly comedic road race between the Mahanas and the Poatas, each trying to be the first to arrive at an important funeral, to the poignancy of the revelations in the final act, his screenplay lets the story unfold with a warmth and depth that captures both Māori culture and a universality of generational conflict in equal measure.

The glorious New Zealand countryside is stunningly captured by cinematographer Ginny Loane and the early'60s time-trame is lovingly evoked by Mark Robins’ production design and art direction by Ross McGarva and Peter Sweeney. But it’s the performances that really lift the story off the screen. Morrison is compelling as the grandfather. He smoulders through scene after scene exuding the authority of the patriarch whilst Keefe counters that role with equal strength, embodying rebellious and idealistic youth. Their clashes are terrific. But it’s Brunning who is pivotal to the drama with a performance that is, at first, unassuming but slowly gathers pace as her importance to the story slowly becomes clearer.

Those hoping that Tamahori’s filmic home-coming would produce something with the confronting narrative and violent edge of Once Were Warriors will no doubt find this film a bit on the gentle side and it is reminiscent of 1970s period dramas with their carefully measured narratives. But those with a taste for a family story told through strong and engaging characters should find Mahana to be just the ticket.




Want more about this film?

search youtube  search wikipedia  

Want something different?

random vintage best worst