Browse all reviews by letter     A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 0 - 9

USA 1972
Directed by
Douglas Trumball
86 minutes
Rated PG

Reviewed by
Bernard Hemingway
3 stars

Silent Running

Douglas Trumbull was a Canadian visual effects pioneer with 2001: A Space Odyssey (1969) on his C.V. when he tackled this his first effort as a director. It is an oddity that despite not having Kubrick's grand vision, nevertheless manages to be surprisingly effective as a 'green" clarion call and today has perhaps even more poignancy than it did when made.
Bruce Dern plays Freeman Lowell, an interplanetary greenhouse keeper on one of the many space station that orbit Earth preserving the last vestiges of Mother Nature now that Earth itself is nothing but a climate-controlled conurbation. Lowell is a genuine tree-hugger and when the powers-that-be decide that it no longer makes sense to keep these museum pieces and orders them blown up, he rebels, kills his colleagues and disappears into deep space.

Whilst one can certainly see points of comparison with Kubrick's film, albeit on a much smaller budget, Silent Running has its own charms thanks (given that these matters touch you) to the sincerity of its ecological message well embodied by Bruce Dern as an astronautical flowerchild and the simple way that it is presented. Dern’s performance is, to say the least, exaggerated but in many ways he needs to be to justify his in extremis behaviour - Lowell is a man who is passionate about his values, no tame conformist, a precusor to the eco-warrior.

If the early stages of the film show Trumball’s lack of directorial experience and often look like they are in spoof territory like John Carpenter’s Dark Star (1974), once Lowell is left alone with only his little robot companions, Huey and Dewey, the film acquires a strangely poignant quality that made me think of Dorothy in the Land of Oz (unfortunately instead we get two songs by hippie diva, Joan Baez), a quality that goes a long way to explaining the film’s cult status.

Probably not a film for straight sci-fi fans but if you enjoyed the Lost In Space television series this will probably give you some pleasure.

FYI: The script was co-written by Michael (then calling himself Mike) Cimino with Deric Washburn who would work with him on The Deer Hunter (1978) and TV writer Steven (then calling himself Steve) Bochco.




Want something different?

random vintage best worst